Our Team

At Overstreet Realty we are a Team of Real Estate Agents within Panama City, FL and the nearby areas, providing home-buyers and sellers with professional, responsive and attentive real estate services. Want an agent who’ll really listen to what you want in a home? Need an agent who knows how to effectively market your home so it sells? Give us a call today! We are eager to help and would love to talk to you.

MaryAnn Enfinger, Owner B55730

MaryAnn Enfinger

Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (850) 832-5263

My name is MaryAnn. I am a native Floridian and fifth generation Bay County resident. Currently I am the Broker/Owner of Overstreet Realty and have been in Real Estate since 2001 in Bay County and surrounding Counties. I am passionate about my customers and meeting all their buying and selling needs. Give us a call, text, or email today, so we can start unlocking doors for you!

Molly Shores, REALTOR B10607

MOLLY Shores

Mobile: (850) 624-1448

Hey y’all my name is Molly Shores, I am a real estate associate for Overstreet Realty in Panama City, FL. I was born and raised in Panama City and I am so grateful & blessed to have the opportunity to sell beautiful homes and property here and in the surrounding areas. Whether you’re looking for a perfect home or vacant land I got you covered. The Florida Panhandle has more than enough to offer, so please call me as I work throughout the panhandle for your buying, selling, and overall real estate needs.


LORENA Buchenhorst

Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (850) 832-4567

Realtor since 1994, specializing in foreclosures, serving Bay, Washington, Jackson and Holmes counties.

Kelsey Ellis, REALTOR B8138

REALTOR, Licensed Assistant

Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (850) 257-6510

Watch here for my bio!

Lisa Franklin, REALTOR B4459

LISA Franklin
Broker Associate

Mobile: (850) 832-0495

Watch here for my bio!

Coreatha Garner, REALTOR B6093


Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (850) 252-0414

Hello, My name is Coreatha Ware Garner. I am an experienced realtor who will help to negotiate the best terms to ensure quality service for any real estate transaction. I will give suggestions to point out improvements that will maximize resale in the future. I was born and raised in Florida, where I know the market’s nature and the opportunities available for investors or first-time homeowners. I have been a licensed Realtor since 2015 and would be a great asset to any real estate transaction.

Cathy Jones, REALTOR B7253

Cathy J Jones

Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (850) 814-0733

Cathy J Jones has dedicated the last 22+ years to selling Real Estate in the NW Florida Panhandle, full time, and since she is also a Panama City Native/Local, She knows Bay County and the surrounding counties, such as the older, established neighborhoods, the up and coming neighborhoods and newest, hottest neighborhoods. For the investor, she has you covered and been the top HUD Listing agent for the past 12 years and she knows how to get you the best deal in the fast paced foreclosure market. So like the sign says, “Just Call Cathy” to list your property or to help you find your place in the sun.

Sharon Wicker, REALTOR B7330


Office: (850) 763-4459
Mobile: (501) 912-1999

My name is Sharon Wicker. I’ve been in Bay County most of my life and around the world’s most beautiful beaches. I love spending time with family, friends, and anything to do with our beautiful waters and boating. I have owned condos in Panama City Beach and currently live in Southport, Florida. I’m proudly the child of a military family and Military Relocation Professional (MRP),REALTOR.  Give me a call or text. I’d love to help you find your next home!!

Tifany Sims, Florida REALTOR


Mobile: (850) 896-6437


Watch here for my bio!


PAULA Rodriguez

Mobile: (770) 309-8705

Watch here for my bio!